How to Choose the Perfect Platform for Your E-Commerce Store (the First Time Around)

By Lucas DiPietrantonio July 1 2019

As a busy professional (or so I’d like to think), the tyranny of choice plagues me more than I care to admit. Im often faced with several solutions to a single problem, each one with its own pros and cons.

 

Big decisions — like what platform you should choose for your e-commerce store—can consume a lot of your time and energy. Luckily, with the right knowledge, it is possible to make the choice thats best for your company.

 

Shopify

 

Shopify is among the most popular e-commerce platforms worldwide, and for good reason. The Shopify platform was built and designed for online entrepreneurs by e-comm entrepreneurs. With this platform, youll have access to seemingly countless apps, plugins, integrations and other personalization features that can help your website stand out from the competition and, more importantly, optimize it for conversions.

 

This platform continues to surprise me year over year by its improvements (recently, this year at Shopify Unite—their annual conference—they rolled out a new 3D visual graphic and AR product experience as well as increased storefront customization capabilities on their backend content management system). These are all positives for end users, entrepreneurs, and e-commerce enthusiasts looking to improve their shopping experiences and get things done with minimal friction.

 

Additionally, on other platforms, you may spend hours writing code and programming for different functionalities. With Shopify, you may have to hire a developer for specific business needs or functionalities but you can just as easily work from a template to get your store up and running in no time.  

 

Of course, all these benefits come at a cost. Shopify charges about $29 monthly for a standard plan—but it is a small price to pay for the value they deliver. Part of  building on Shopify means access to their ecosystem of thousands of applications—some that increase conversions through customer engagement, cart abandonment recovery, and product upsells at checkout (shout-out to my friends over at Carthook). The strength of their content management system and application ecosystem makes managing and growing an online business as easy as is currently possible (from my knowledge). 

 

To see if Shopify is right for your company, you can take advantage of their free 14-day trial.

 

You can try a free 15-day trial of BigCommerce to compare the two sites before purchasing.

 

Magento


To offer all the features that online stores need, Magento can seem somewhat complex to the untrained eye. If you are unwilling to learn a computer language or hire a programmer, Magento might not be the platform for you.

 

Entrepreneurs who are willing to put in the extra time will fall in love with Magentos out-of-the-box and add-on features. However, I will say that Magento is better suited for well-established retail stores or merchants with a need for complex and more customizable experiences. Naturally, this comes at a higher cost and maintenance fee. For these reasons, I’d probably recommend Magento for only specific stores that fit the criteria. Even still, I am finding myself migrating more and more stores pre-established on Magento to Shopify just for its ease of use and the growing strength of the Shopify ecosystem.

 

Another large benefit of Magento is its enhanced security; due to its complexity and special-purpose build, the platform is one of the most secure available. In terms of drawbacks, again, if youre not a programmer, willing to hire a programmer or going to learn some programming, Magento isnt the logical choice for you.

 

WooCommerce

 

Many first-time business owners are drawn to this website builder because theres no set monthly subscription fee. WooCommerce is a free plugin that allows WordPress websites (which account for 25% of the web) to become online stores.

 

That being said, you will likely have to pay for some of the features youre going to need to have a successful online store. Fortunately, desired plugins are often readily available and well-coded. Still, its advisable to know HTML and CSS if you use this platform. Because it is free, its user interface isnt as optimized as other platforms. 

 

A major drawback to WooCommerce is that the WordPress backend isn’t as organized as Magento or Shopify because it isn’t specifically designed for high-volume revenue generating e-commerce stores. For these reasons, I normally add WooCommerce onto sites that are not specifically meant for e-commerce—meaning that isn’t their main driver of revenue. For instance, we recently built a beautiful storefront for a pre-launch, posh LA restaurant Violet (the restaurant opens this Fall). The main CTA of the website is to book a table—the main driver of revenue. The restaurant proprietors also wanted us to build a custom cooking class reservation feature—for aspirational or curious cooks who wanted to stay after hours for impromptu cooking classes with celebrity chef Dana Slatkin. Here, we integrated a WooCommerce plugin for the Wordpress built site to enable a checkout feature, and voilà, we have online checkout functionality and a perfect use-case for WooCommerce.

 

Squarespace

 

If you are searching for an aesthetically pleasing website, Squarespace might be the platform for you. Its easy to use and makes picking design layouts simple. There are over 100 flexible templates — for desktop and mobile devices — that you can adapt for your needs.

 

Without knowing a single computer language, its possible to create a stunning website on Squarespace. Also, if anything goes wrong, Squarespace is known for timely and professional customer service. It costs $26 or $40 monthly to have a Squarespace online store.

 

One drawback of Squarespace is that it doesnt have an app store and therefore, I can’t even consider it in the same domain as Shopify or Magento. Although you can still add apps to your site, they are not as integrated as on Shopify; main point here is that Squarespace wasn't intentionally built for e-commerce. 

 

Online Marketplaces

 

Sites like Etsy, eBay and Amazon can boost your sales, but they shouldnt be your only e-commerce platform. Sure, they will help your products get views, but will they ensure loyal customers? Are they worth the high fees?

 

An online marketplace can supplement your revenue and product sales, but it cant be the be-all or end-all. You dont have to discount established online retailers, but they shouldn't represent your only product marketplace (at least in my opinion). Of course, there are high-revenue retailers that only distribute via marketplaces—and do so with great success. If you can make this work, then more power to you.

 

What Do I Use?

 

When it comes to my e-commerce businesses, I trust Shopify and Magento. Ive worked with other sites, and I keep coming back to the two aforementioned platforms. I defer to and rely on (and recommend) Shopify for about 99% of e-commerce businesses I see come across my desk. However, Magento is a platform specifically designed for high-volume, customizable storefronts and when used for the right use-case is the perfect choice.

 

Still, the platforms I use might not be the right ones for your business. Based on the information above, you should be able to make a timely and educated choice for your company’s e-commerce platform.

Spread the word

Further reading

Freshly squeezed.

By signing up, you agree to Darkroom’s Terms & Conditions, and Privacy Policy.

Have an idea for a start-up? We invest time & resources in new projects.

Learn more
.