menu

menu

coffee mugs comparison

AI Search

Power Digital vs. Darkroom: Services, Pricing, AI, and Which Agency Fits You Best

Written by Darkroom leardership

11 min read

Nov 16, 2026

SHARE

These days, just about every growth agency on a 2026 shortlist claims to be AI-native. In reality, only a handful truly are, and Power Digital and Darkroom both make that cut. Each agency brings its own proprietary AI and offers full-funnel programs designed specifically for consumer brands.

When choosing between these agencies, the main questions are usually clear: what will it cost, who will manage your account, and how does each agency’s AI use your data to make budget decisions?

To make things easier, this guide covers a side-by-side comparison of services, structure, pricing, AI, results, and overall fit of both agencies. We sourced and verified every fact so you can trust the details.


Main differences between Power Digital and Darkroom

Power Digital and Darkroom are both AI-focused growth marketing agencies working with consumer brands, but they take different approaches. Power Digital, based in San Diego, uses specialized teams alongside its Omega AI platform and only shares pricing after a free audit.

Darkroom, headquartered in New York, assigns a senior strategist to oversee 14 services, uses its Shadow platform for planning, and is upfront about its starting prices.


Comparison

Power Digital

Darkroom

Pricing

Power Digital publishes no fees on its site, as of November 2026, and offers a custom growth plan after a free audit

Darkroom publishes a starting price for all 14 services, from $2,500/mo

Account leaders

Power Digital assigns niche experts, an account manager, and a veteran account director, with an Executive Sponsor acting as team CMO

Darkroom assigns one dedicated senior strategist accountable across channels, from $10,000/mo

Service menu

Power Digital lists four groups, Growth Marketing, Data Intelligence, Consulting and Creative, plus Amazon and TikTok Shop marketplaces

Darkroom runs 14 services as one program

AI systems

Power Digital runs Iris, Omega and Creative Affinity, launched August 2026

Darkroom runs Shadow, the most advanced marketing agent in the world, and the Flight Plan

Ownership

Power Digital is privately held, with a Court Square Capital Partners investment since March 2022

Darkroom is founder-owned and operates as Darkroom Digital, Inc., with Shadow as its AI sister company

Built for

Power Digital runs divisions for B2B, Consumer Services, CPG, Fashion, Healthcare, and Lifestyle

Darkroom serves enterprise consumer brands selling DTC, on marketplaces and in retail

Where Power Digital stands out

Power Digital stands out in three key areas that set it apart from other agencies:

  • Power Digital brings earned media in-house, with dedicated teams for PR, affiliate marketing, and influencer partnerships. This means clients get a more integrated approach to building brand awareness and credibility.

  • Power Digital goes beyond just consumer goods. Specialized teams focus on B2B, healthcare, and consumer services, so brands in these sectors get tailored expertise.

Where Darkroom stands out

Darkroom, on the other hand, stands out in four main ways:

  • Darkroom publishes starting prices for each of its 14 services. This level of transparency makes it easier for brands to understand what to expect before starting a conversation.

  • Every client works with one senior strategist who is accountable for results across all channels. This single point of contact helps keep campaigns aligned and communication clear.

  • Darkroom offers a 'brand to shelf' approach. Brand Studio, website development, Amazon, TikTok Shop, retail media, and retention are all managed within one cohesive program so that brands can streamline their efforts from start to finish.

  • The agency integrates AI directly into your existing tech stack. Shadow platform pulls insights from the tools you already use, while your team follows a weekly Flight Plan to stay on track and optimize performance.


Which services does each agency offer?

Both agencies offer a broad mix of services, including paid media, Amazon and TikTok Shop support, SEO and generative engine optimization, CRO, email and SMS marketing, and creative work.

Power Digital's service menu

As of November 2026, these groups are listed on Power Digital’s services page:

  • Growth Marketing: paid media, earned media through PR, affiliate and influencer, and owned media from SEO and GEO to email, SMS and CRO.

  • Data Intelligence: data infrastructure and CDPs, measurement and incrementality, MMM and data science, and marketing operations.

  • Consulting: go-to-market strategy, media planning scenarios and persona development.

  • Creative: creative strategy, plus brand, design and editing.

Power Digital expanded its marketplace team in September 2026 by acquiring Pirawna, an Amazon agency, and Uptickk, which specializes in TikTok Shop and affiliate marketing. The CPG division now supports retail and commerce strategies across platforms like Amazon, Walmart, Target, Instacart, direct-to-consumer, and social commerce.

Darkroom's service menu

Darkroom runs 14 services through one integrated team: Growth Strategy, Paid Media, Performance Creative, Creator Content, TikTok Shop, Amazon, Retail Media, Retention, CRO, AI Search, Organic Social, Brand Studio, Website Development, and Website Support.

For consumer tech or CPG brands, this means one team can handle everything from building a brand identity and storefront to launching in marketplaces and retail, all while planning acquisition and retention with a unified approach.

Darkroom works across several verticals, including consumer technology, electronics and hardware, food and beverage, and beauty and fragrance. Brands can choose to start with just one service or tap into the full suite as needed.


darkroom executive team and ai-native agency leaders in a group photo

Darkroom's executive team.


How the two agencies are built and staffed

Power Digital organizes around industry divisions with a multi-role account team. Darkroom assigns one senior strategist to every account.

How Power Digital is built

Power Digital is based in San Diego and was founded in 2012. Its company page lists offices in San Diego, New York, Medellín, and Atlanta, names CEO Jeff Mason, and describes the firm as privately held.

Power Digital Marketing runs six divisions: B2B, Consumer Services, CPG, Fashion, Healthcare and Lifestyle, each pairing vertical experts with Omega. 

Its services page describes each client team as niche experts, an account manager, and a veteran account director, with an Executive Sponsor acting as team CMO and weekly calls.

How Darkroom is built

At Darkroom, one senior strategist is accountable for outcomes across your channels. That full-stack marketer owns growth strategy, measurement, financial pacing, and investment decisions from $10,000 a month, with channel teams underneath.

Senior leaders steward client accounts, including Julie Novak, MD of Social Commerce, Nick Menicucci, MD of Marketplaces and Retail Media, and Peter Gao, SVP of Growth.

Darkroom reviews more than 500 consumer marketing P&Ls a year, so your strategist plans with patterns from comparable brands.

Before you sign with either agency, ask each one to name the person who will own your P&L conversation in month one, and meet that person.


What does each agency charge?

Darkroom makes it easy to see what you might pay by listing starting prices for all 14 of its services. Power Digital, on the other hand, offers a free audit first and then puts together a custom growth plan with pricing tailored to your needs.

How Power Digital prices its work

Power Digital does not publish its pricing on its website, which is something to keep in mind when comparing agencies. Instead, the site highlights a free marketing audit and promises a custom growth plan, as seen on its homepage and services pages as of November 2026.

It’s a good idea to ask Power Digital for details about their fee structure and any minimum commitments in writing before you get the results of your audit.

How Darkroom prices its work

Darkroom lists a starting price for all 14 services, grouped here by the job a consumer tech or CPG program needs:

  • Marketplace and shelf: Retail Media from $2,500/mo, Amazon from $6,000/mo, and TikTok Shop from $6,500/mo.

  • Acquisition: Paid Media from $5,000/mo, Creator Content from $5,000/mo, and Performance Creative from $8,000/mo.

  • Retention and site: Retention from $5,000/mo, CRO from $5,250/mo, and Website Support from $3,500.

  • Strategy and brand: Growth Strategy from $10,000/mo, Brand Studio from $12,500, and Website Development from $60,000.

  • Discovery: AI Search from $4,500/mo and Organic Social from $6,000/mo.

Here are two examples of how these fees might add up, not including media spend:

  • Marketplace-led CPG program: Amazon, TikTok Shop and Retail Media start from $15,000 a month in fees.

  • Consumer tech launch: Growth Strategy, Paid Media and Performance Creative start from $23,000 a month in fees.

After the free audit, you’ll get a detailed quote based on these starting prices. You can review and approve the specific services, the order in which they’ll be delivered, and the budget before any work begins.


How do Omega and Shadow compare?

Omega is Power Digital's AI growth operating system, launched in August 2026. Shadow, on the other hand, is Darkroom's AI commerce layer. One standout feature of Shadow is the Flight Plan, which turns its insights into a live, actionable plan.

Power Digital's Omega and Iris

In August 2026, Power Digital introduced Iris, Omega, and Creative Affinity. According to Power Digital, Omega helps by ranking opportunities, answering questions about your data through Chat, and handling approved production work using agents. The process is simple: the team approves, agents execute, and every action gets logged for transparency.

Iris is Power Digital's proprietary model, trained on more than ten years of client performance data. This model powers both the answers you get and the agents that carry out tasks. Creative Affinity analyzes creative assets to predict how well they might perform.

Omega sits on top of Power Digital Nova, the company's broader technology ecosystem. It uses a semantic layer in Looker and Snowflake to organize and analyze data. Clients can get early access to Omega through the Co-Pilot program.

Darkroom's Shadow and its Flight Plan

Shadow, Darkroom's AI commerce layer, helps build and update your media mix model. It also runs root-cause analysis whenever your numbers change and suggests budget reallocations, all scored against contribution profit. This means every recommendation is already speaking the language your finance team uses: contribution margin.

Shadow connects directly with platforms like Shopify, Amazon, Meta, Google, Klaviyo, and GA4. The best part is that it reads from these sources without requiring any data migration, so your existing setup stays the same.

The Flight Plan acts as a live roadmap, tying together your goals, commerce P&L, media investments, and daily pacing. Teams review it together every week and month to stay on track.


Read also: What an AI-Native Agency Actually Looks Like


Shadow AI platform demo ecossistem, with prompt examples.

Shadow's platform.

Published results from both agencies

Both agencies regularly share case studies focused on CPG and consumer brands. To compare them clearly, match each result to its specific metric, channel, and time period before concluding.

What results does Power Digital share?

On its CPG division page, Power Digital highlights feedback from Hershey's marketing team. In 2025, Hershey's DTC program beat its MER target by 105% and brought in 83% more revenue than expected. Chocolate World also saw foot traffic come in 10% above goal, all while spending 12% less than planned.

Power Digital's Catalina Crunch case study reports an investment announcement: +47 % Amazon revenue and +144% Instacart revenue, year over year.

What results does Darkroom share?

Sauz is a good example of a brand that started from scratch. Darkroom handled everything from building the brand identity and packaging for more than seven SKUs to launching the Shopify site. They also managed paid media, Amazon, and retention efforts as Sauz expanded into nearly 7,000 retail locations.

On Amazon, Everlane grew revenue by more than 123% across 87 ASINs launched with brand-grade creative.

Olipop partnered with Darkroom for its first national media campaign, running across CTV, YouTube, and Meta. According to Darkroom, this campaign led to a threefold increase in revenue.


Which agency fits your brand?

Start by looking at where your revenue comes from and which services you need bundled into a single contract. Here’s a simple three-step process to help guide your decision:

  1. Map the last 12 months of revenue across DTC, Amazon, TikTok Shop, and retail.

  2. Mark the services that must sit in one contract, such as PR or a CDP build.

  3. Take the same brief to both audits and compare quotes line by line.

When Power Digital fits better

  • If you want earned media like PR, affiliate, and influencer marketing managed together with your paid and owned media, Power Digital can bring all of these under one contract.

  • For brands looking for help with data infrastructure, Power Digital offers standalone projects like CDP builds, MMM, data science, and marketing operations.

  • Power Digital also has dedicated divisions for B2B, healthcare, and consumer services, so each sector has specialized support.

When Darkroom fits better

  • If your revenue comes from a mix of DTC, marketplaces, and retail, Darkroom can bring everything together under one plan, covering Shopify, Amazon, TikTok Shop, and retail media.

  • Transparency is a big plus with Darkroom, since they publish 14 starting prices upfront so you know what to expect before any pitch.

  • With Darkroom, a senior strategist takes ownership of your account and is accountable for results across all channels.

  • Profit is the main scorecard at Darkroom. Their Shadow and Flight Plan programs are designed to track and plan against contribution profit.

  • Darkroom also brings Brand Studio, website development, and media into one program, just as they did for Sauz.

If your business is B2B SaaS or focused on lead generation without a transactional storefront, another agency might be a better fit. But for consumer tech and CPG commerce brands, 

Darkroom stands out as an alternative to Power Digital, thanks to its published pricing and dedicated senior owner.


Read also: Top Technology Marketing Agencies in the US: The 12 Best for 2026


Why Darkroom plans every program against contribution profit

In short, both agencies focus on delivering full-funnel growth, with AI playing a central role in their approach.

Power Digital brings together specialized teams and their Omega platform, then determines fees after completing an audit. Darkroom, on the other hand, is transparent from the start, publishing starting prices for all 14 services.

Each channel gets a dedicated senior strategist, and planning is done with Shadow and the Flight Plan, always focusing on contribution profit and using your own analytics tools.

There are three main reasons behind this approach:

  • Published prices mean you can see exactly what a program might cost before even getting on a call.

  • With one accountable strategist, a single expert owns your plan, measurement, and pacing from start to finish.

  • Profit is measured right inside your own stack, with Shadow and the Flight Plan tracking contribution profit using the analytics tools you already have.

The most reliable test is your own data. A 30-minute session with a senior Darkroom strategist gives you a chance to review your channel mix, customer acquisition cost, and contribution margin together.

In the first week, you’ll receive a channel-by-channel audit ranked by revenue opportunity, along with a quote you can easily compare to other prices. The audit is yours to keep, no matter what you decide.

Get your free growth audit



FAQs

Is Power Digital or Darkroom better for a CPG brand?

For CPG brands selling directly, on Amazon, TikTok Shop, and in retail stores, Darkroom takes a unified approach. One senior strategist oversees brand, marketplaces, paid media, and retention, and all starting prices are published upfront. Power Digital also has a dedicated CPG division, but stands out if you’re looking for PR, affiliate, and influencer programs all under one roof.

How much does Power Digital cost compared with Darkroom?

Power Digital doesn’t list its pricing online. Instead, you’ll get a custom growth plan after a free audit, so the cost depends on your specific needs. Darkroom takes a different approach by publishing starting prices for all 14 of its services. For example, retail media management starts at $2,500 per month, while a dedicated growth strategist starts at $10,000 per month. Your program is quoted based on these published rates.

When is Darkroom a good Power Digital alternative?

Darkroom is a strong alternative to Power Digital if your growth strategy includes Shopify, Amazon, TikTok Shop, and retail, and you prefer to see pricing before your first call. With one senior strategist owning your plan, it’s designed for consumer brands. If you’re a B2B SaaS company or a lead generation business without a storefront, another agency may be a better fit.

How should you read Power Digital marketing reviews?

Directory reviews are just a starting point. Ask each agency for two references in your category and budget range, then call those references. When reading case studies, look for specific metrics and timelines, and ask which team members from those projects would be working on your account.

Sign up to our newsletter.

Sign up to our newsletter.

Get notified with new content.

Get notified with new content.

Related Content